Friday, September 18, 2015

Review: The Small Backs of Children

An American photographer happens to be in the right place at the right time and snaps an amazing and terrifying picture: a young girl propelled forward by the blast that kills the rest of her family. While the photographer soon leaves the country wracked by war, the girl becomes emblematic for many people, including the photographer's friend who is grieving a terrible loss of her own. When the friend stops writing and plunges into a deep depression, her loved ones decide that the only solution is to find the girl in the photograph.

The characters in this story are unnamed. Instead, they are referred to by their profession - the photographer, the writer, the filmmaker, the poet, and the artist. Even the girl in the photograph is not named until partway through the story. In some moments, it reminded me of Angels In America as the characters grappled with art and the self, and the way they related to others and to the world. Does acclaim matter? Does finding success as an artist mean you have to give up the things that most make you yourself? What do we lose when we co-opt people for our artistic expression and is it ethical to do so? Can you be famous and make good art? Does giving expression to the darkness in our lives help us to battle it?

The best word to describe this book is brutal. Everything within its pages is dark and painful. This is not the story for any person who has difficulty reading about violence in any setting. Yuknavitch walks a fine line with this story between portraying the prevalence and severity of violence (especially that towards women) and creating violence for the sake of shock. Her characters can be ridiculously pretentious when it comes to their art but, then again, we get the idea of narcissistic artists from somewhere. The characters with no names almost seem representative as opposed to fully developed ones.

In some ways, the story seems to be incidental to Yuknavitch's exploration of pain and art. In fact, she provides readers with several endings without any indication which one actually occurred. The Small Backs of Children is a book for the reader who is unafraid to take risks and can face darkness and pain head on, the one who wonders if the relief of finding a common experience is a start to healing the pain, or the person who believes that art can bring solace to the grief we are faced with again and again in this life.


The Small Backs of Children
By Lidia Yuknavitch
Harper July 2015
224 pages
From the library

9 comments:

  1. I can imagine "brutal" is a very apt adjective to describe this book. The paragraph you wrote in the very beginning makes my eyes widen at the shock of that situation, and of course the grief must be near unbearable. The cover seems an absolutely perfect fit for the story, which doesn't always happen (in my opinion).

    ReplyDelete
  2. I can imagine "brutal" is a very apt adjective to describe this book. The paragraph you wrote in the very beginning makes my eyes widen at the shock of that situation, and of course the grief must be near unbearable. The cover seems an absolutely perfect fit for the story, which doesn't always happen (in my opinion).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's very dark and hard to read. I think sometimes the books that hurt our heart or shock us are important to read. The cover is pretty perfect. It's a wonderful example of the cover reflecting the book inside.

      Delete
  3. Those are some great questions to address in a novel.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree. This is one of those books you think about for a long time after it's done.

      Delete
  4. I received a copy of this one and was on the fence about reading it. Your review made me glad I kept it and added it to my TBR shelves, even with the violence.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's so tough to know which review copies are going to be worth the time. This one is hard to read but it's an unforgettable one.

      Delete
  5. I'm very interested in the ethical questions this addresses, but the brutal violence sounds like too much for me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is certainly tough to take. There were a few places where I put the book down and came back later.

      Delete