Thursday, August 6, 2015

Mystery and Adventure Mini-Reviews: The Last Bookaneer and Murder on the Orient Express

Clover is an underpaid and poorly treated porter on a train line. His happiest days are when a bookseller named Fergins comes on board and tells him stories about his life. Fergins was an assistant to an infamous bookaneer named Pen Davenport. Bookaneers are literary pirates who steal manuscripts to publish, often without the author's permission. Davenport and Fergins take a dangerous journey on their last and perhaps greatest mission - to steal the final novel of Robert Louis Stevenson from his island home. But they will have to outsmart the island's natives, a rival bookaneer, and the author himself to complete this mission.

I loved the idea of this book. What could possibly be cooler than literary pirates? But I found the actual execution rather lacking. Nothing in this story is experienced firsthand - instead, we get Fergins relating something that didn't even happen to him to Clover. Fergins doesn't tell a particularly quick tale. Instead, he meanders and then comes back...eventually. I wish there weren't so many frames to the story - Clover isn't a particularly compelling character, aside from the insight into the ways that people of color were treated at the end of the 19th century. I wanted to love this book but in the end, I found myself wishing it was shorter and that it took me on a greater adventure.

The Last Bookaneer
By Matthew Pearl
Penguin Press April 2015
400 pages
Read via Netgalley



The Orient Express is speeding through the night when it is stopped by a snowstorm. Soon, the passengers discover that someone has been murdered. Samuel Ratchett lies stabbed in his sleeping compartment, behind a locked door. In a most fortunate bit of happenstance, brilliant detective Hercule Poirot is on the train. He quickly deduces that someone on the train must be the murderer. But can he figure out which one did it?

This was not my first Christie, but it was my first time experiencing the wonderful Hercule Poirot. I was smitten early in the story when he stated, "I do not like your face." The mystery, as expected, was wonderful. I was guessing until the very end and the solution still surprised me. Murder on the Orient Express is the perfect book to listen to instead of reading on the page. Sometimes it is difficult to keep track of details in an audiobook, but Poirot goes over the evidence several times as he interviews various passengers and proposes theories to his companions. The narration is absolutely perfect. Dan Stevens does a great job of narrating characters of different ages, sexes, and nationalities and each one sounds just as they should. Listening to Murder on the Orient Express is everything you could hope it would be.

Murder on the Orient Express
By Agatha Christie
HarperAudio September 2013; originally published in 1934
Narrated by Dan Stevens
6 1/2 hours
From the library 

14 comments:

  1. I've never read Agatha Christie, but I think if I start, I want to read this one first!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Apparently it's the 10th Poirot mystery but I hadn't read any of the previous ones. They don't seem to affect each other.

      Delete
  2. The narrative distance of The Last Bookaneer kind of bugged me as well. It's like we're hearing the story third-hand. I'd rather just experience the events! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Exactly! The distance made me feel like I never got to really know any of the characters.

      Delete
  3. Sorry The Last Bookaneer wasn't better, but I'm not surprised it read slow. The last Matthew Pearl novel I read really dragged. At least the Christie was good. (But then she's always a fun read.)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This was my first time reading anything by Matthew Pearl. Which one of his have you read?

      Delete
    2. I've read The Dante Club, which I liked, and The Poe Shadow, which was good, but seemed really slow-moving for some reason. I heard from another blogger that The Last Dickens dragged, too, but I haven't read that one.

      Delete
  4. I have "The Last Bookaneer" on hold at the library and should get it pretty soon. Bummer that you didn't like it better! I've been meaning to read Agatha Christie forever. It sounds like "Murder on the Orient Express" might be a perfect place to start!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Murder on the Orient Express was pretty great! I get why so many readers love Christie.

      Delete
  5. I really want to get in to reading more of Agatha Christie's works. All I've read currently is the much loved, And Then There Were None.

    All Things Bookish – Jade Louise

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've read that one too!. There are just so many of them that I don't know which one to pick next!

      Delete
  6. I felt the same way about The Last Bookaneer! I had high hopes for it, but the way the story was told didn't work for me.

    I love Agatha Christie, especially her Poirot mysteries, and Murder On the Orient Express is a classic! I'm glad you ended up enjoying it :) Like Jade, I love And Then There Were None, so that might be a good choice for your next Christie read :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Do you have a favorite Poirot? I think I could spend some more time with him! :)

      Delete
  7. Orient Express was my second Christie and I liked it much more than my first (And Then There Were None). I bet it would be excellent on audio - glad you enjoyed!

    ReplyDelete